Ontario's Historical Plaques 

Discover Ontario's history as told through its plaques

2004 - Now in our 15th Year - 2019

 To find out all about me, you can visit the Home Page 

Looking at this page on a smartphone?
For best viewing, hold your phone
in Landscape mode (Horizontal)

Silver Islet 1868

Silver Islet 1868

Photo by contributor Jocelyn Gordon - Posted August, 2005

Silver Islet 1868

Photo from Google Street View ©2010 Google - Posted October, 2010

Silver Islet 1868

Photo Source - Unknown

Plaque Location

The District of Thunder Bay
The Township of Shuniah
In Sleeping Giant Provincial Park
on Highway 587 at its most southerly point

Coordinates: N 48 19.853 W 88 49.198


Plaque Text

Off this shore lies Silver Islet, once a barren rock measuring about 25 metres in diameter, where silver was discovered in 1868 by Thomas Macfarlane. The claim was purchased in 1870 by a company headed by A.H. Sibley, and one of the partners, W.B. Frue, was appointed mine captain. Frue waged a constant battle against the lake which undermined extensive crib work used to bolster the restricted working space. Despite this problem and the difficulty of housing miners and transporting supplies in the isolated region, this famous mine produced $3,250,000 worth of silver ore before it was closed in 1884.

Related Ontario plaques
Silver Mining in Canada
Cobalt Mining Camp
Cobalt Mining
Oliver Daunais 1836-1916



Shuniah Plaques

Here are the visitors' comments for this page.

> Posted July 28, 2016
Hello. On Nov 11, 1874 George McInnis, age 21 (or 26) married Christina McPherson age 21 at Silver Islet, Ontario. The Marriage Registration is available on ancestry.ca or thru the Ontario Archives. Christina McPherson is my half grandaunt. She was born in Scotland and I have the full McPherson family history from 1801 to current. George and Christina moved to (or lived in) Houghton Twp., Keweenaw, Michigan where George died. Christina returned to the area east of Owen Sound and is listed on the 1891 census as Christina McGinnis and her three youngest children and then she moved to Bellingham, Washington, USA where she lived until her death in 1914. On the Marriage Registration the witnesses are Alexander McPherson, who is possibly a family member and Margaret Campbell whom I know nothing about. If anyone can provide information about Alexander and Margaret it would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you, Murray Cook macook99@icloud.com

> Posted December 7, 2009
I am very humbled to see this photo of a plaque that honors my great grandfather Captain William Bell Frue. Ironically, my husband was born, raised and schooled in Toronto, and left to go off to pursue his PhD in Biology over 30 years ago. He has promised me that one day when we drive up to visit his brother and family in Ontario that we will detour north and spend some time at Silver Islet. I would love to take a photo of me standing beside this plaque. I do thank you for keeping the legacy alive, and am proud of the role Captain Frue played not only in mining but especially in Canadian history. Until then, I remain,
Sincerely yours, Patricia Calhoun Bell Frue Wainberg, Daisy's Hill Farm, Lula, GA 30554 USA, daisyshillfarm@bellsouth.net

> Posted August 27, 2009
Our family visited the village of Silver Island on the recommendation of an acquiantence. We were struck by the unspoiled surroundings. The developed area is rustic, even primitive, but there are few dilapidated structures. Many of the buildings date from the mining era 130 years ago and are still maintained as permanent residences today. Visiting Silver Island was the high point of our vacation.
John Reese, Saint Paul MN U.S.A.

> Posted March 17, 2009
My wife and I visited Silver Islet last summer and had a great time visiting with the locals. My Great great grandfather was Thomas Macfarlane. I was very surprised to see the monumental plaque honoring my relative. The couple who owned the supply store were helpful, and we had a great visit with them discussing their store and history. We also met the great granddaughter of Captain Cross. We went to see the islet thinking it would just be a place we could see and say we went to, and never dreamed we'd see such a piece of our history, and Canada's. We're so happy to have visited one of Canada's historical sites.
Sincerely; Kent and Terry Macfarlane, Vernon, BC, scotbig2@telus.net

Here's where you can send me a comment for this page.

Note: Your email address will be posted at the end of your comment so others can respond to you unless you request otherwise.

Note: Comments are moderated. Yours will appear on this page within 24 hours (usually much sooner).

Note: As soon as I have posted your comment, a reply to your email will be sent informing you.

To send me your comment, click alanlangfordbrown@gmail.com.

Alan L Brown

Note: If you wish to send me a personal email, click here.